Jump To Navigation
12/15/2005 Charlotte Observer - Huggins Trial Verdict

Charlotte Observer



28.5 Million Dollar Verdict for the Wrongful Death of Rev. Ronel Huggins


GEORGETOWN, S.C.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Dec. 15, 2005--A Sumter County, SC jury on Thursday afternoon returned a verdict of $28.5 million dollars against Eastern Healthcare Group. J. Edward Bell, III and C. Carter Elliott, Jr., of the Bell Legal Group and Eugene C. Fulton, Jr. represented the family of Rev. Ronel Huggins in the wrongful death claim against Eastern Healthcare Group, the company responsible for providing health care for the Sumter County Detention Center. The jury awarded the family $21 million dollars in actual damages and $7.5 million dollars in punitive damages.

While in the custody of the Sumter County Detention Center in December of 2001, Rev. Huggins, 43, died as a result of the failure of jail medical personnel to give him his diabetic medicine. His diabetic condition was made known to the personnel at the jail. A wrongful death claim was filed against Eastern Healthcare and several other defendants. Earlier in the week, a settlement was reached with the other defendants but the case continued against Eastern. Mr. Bell and Mr. Elliott believed that the death of Rev. Ronel Huggins was senseless, reckless, negligent and completely avoidable.

Rev. Huggins was Pastor of Oaks A.M.E. Church located in Summerton, South Carolina. A known diabetic, Rev. Huggins also suffered from schizophrenia. With regular and proper medication, Rev. Huggins was able to lead a rewarding life. His life came to an end, however, in December of 2001, when his medication became unregulated.

According to Ed Bell of the Bell Legal Group in Georgetown and Sumter, South Carolina, December 23, 2001, Rev. Huggins was brought to Tuomey Hospital by ambulance because friends believed that he "was not acting right." Suffering from a rare medical episode, he was medicated and discharged from the hospital. When Rev. Huggins did not leave immediately from the hospital, Tuomey security personnel escorted him off the hospital premises and tried to send him to a local shelter. On December 24, 2001, Rev. Huggins was returned to the hospital for wandering the street and was still unable to express himself to hospital personnel. Rev. Huggins was again treated and released. Three hours later, Rev. Huggins returned to the hospital and asked the medical staff to please help him because he "was just not feeling right." Medical reports indicated that Rev. Huggins was once again examined by emergency room personnel and released without proper medication or treatment.

Finally on Christmas morning, Rev. Huggins was once again discovered in the emergency room waiting room, unresponsive and exhibiting bizarre behavior. Dazed and disoriented, Rev. Huggins was subsequently arrested and brought to the Sumter County Detention Center. No additional medical care was provided to Rev. Huggins before his arrest.

Rev. Huggins arrived at the jail in a hospital gown and was placed in the "drunk tank" without clothing, blanket, pillow or bed. The Sumter County jail personnel did not complete his intake medical screening. However, they found in his possession his medical discharge form from the previous day and forwarded the document to the jail nurse. The document indicated that Rev. Huggins needed medication.

For the next 24 to 36 hours, Rev Huggins was left alone in the Sumter County "drunk tank." Rev. Huggins died in a cell alone about 12:15 a.m. on December 27, 2001, due to what was believed to be diabetic ketoacidosis, a state of absolute or relative insulin deficiency aggravated by ensuing hyperglycemia, dehydration, and acidosis-producing derangements in intermediary metabolism. He was found in his cell about 2:25 a.m. by the jail staff lying face-down.

"He died on a tile floor with no one to care for him, no one thinking of him. This case is the death of a man that was profoundly mistreated," said attorney J. Edward Bell. Mr. Bell went on to say that the defendants in the lawsuit violated their own policies, which included never leaving a mentally ill patient unattended; screening inmates at the prison for such problems; and providing 24-hour medical care for the jail, among others.

Carter Elliott, head of the Police and Jail Misconduct section of the Bell Legal Group, stated that the jail nurse, an employee of Eastern Healthcare Group, never laid eyes on Rev. Huggins. According to Mr. Elliott, the evidence showed that, after the family had brought Rev. Huggins' medicine to the jail, the nurse refused to take and to administer medicine.

In an earlier separate settlement agreement, the other defendants, Tuomey Hospital, the Tuomey ER doctors, and the Sumter County Detention Center settled the case for a reported $1.7 million dollars.

Mr. Bell stated in his opening and closing argument that "this is a death which should have never happened."

Mr. J. Edward Bell, III was assisted in this case by C. Carter Elliott, Jr. and Vanessa A. Richardson of the Bell Legal Group of Georgetown, SC, and Eugene C. Fulton, Jr. of Columbia, South Carolina. For more information about this verdict, contact J. Edward Bell, III at (843)318-1216 or Rachel Ridgeway of the Law Offices of J. Edward Bell at 843-546-2408 or visit www.edbelllaw.com.

About the Bell Legal Group LLC
The attorneys and staff of the Bell Legal Group focus on select and challenging areas of law and bring 25 years litigation experience. To successfully litigate the large scale cases for which the Bell Legal Group has become known for, the firm offers its own unique reserve of capitol, resources and state of the art technology. Leaving no stone unturned while pursuing justice, the firm has built its reputation concentrating in the areas of automotive defect, medical malpractice, nursing home litigation, personal injury litigation and police misconduct cases. For more information on the Bell Legal Group LLC call 877-546-2408 or visit www.edbelllaw.com.

 

Contact Us

Bell Legal Group
232 King Street
PO Box 2590
Georgetown, SC 29440

Phone: 1-843-461-3021
Toll-Free: 1-866-721-5662

Recent Legal News
  • [09/03] Tractor upgrades reduce farm deaths from rollovers More...[09/02] New CFA Report: 60 mpg or More Standard is Economically Achievable and Truly Responsive to Consumer Needs More...[09/02] First Global Congress for Maritime Environmental Protection "gmec" in Hamburg: Europe's Green Capital 2011 Combines Economy and Ecology More... [09/01] New York imam: Mosque fight about Muslim role More...[08/19] Germany considering income tax equality for gays More...[08/19] Muslim employee: Disney banned her head scarf More... [06/03] One Step Ahead Recalls Children's Stacking Toys Due to Choking and Aspiration Hazard More...[06/01] BRP Recalls Snowmobiles Due to Fire Hazard More...[06/00] Dritz(tm) Electric Scissors Recalled by Prym Due to Fire and Burn Hazards More...[06/00] IKEA Recalls Roller Blinds, all Roman Blinds and all Roll-Up Blinds Due to Risk of Strangulation More... [09/03] A Chance to Meet Justin Bieber Is Just One Click Away More...[09/03] Topman Design Announces 2nd Solo Show to be Held at The Royal Opera House More...[09/03] BP says cost of Gulf of Mexico spill hits $8B More... [09/03] Police question scientist in Miami airport scare More...[09/03] Montana teen accidentally texts sheriff to buy pot More...[09/03] Warrants detail stabbings at Calif. beach house More... [09/03] Goats rescued after 2 days on 6-inch ledge in Mont More...[09/03] Earl weakens but still powerful as it scoots by NC More...[09/03] Dolphins herded in Japanese cove but none killed More... [06/01] Domega NY International Co., LTD Issues Allergy Alert on Undeclared Egg in Fuma Custard Pie More...[06/09] P G Recalls Specific Canned Cat Foods Due to Low Levels of Thiamine (Vitamin B1) More...[06/08] Defibtech Announces a Voluntary Recall of DBP-2800 Battery Packs used in the Lifeline AED sups/sup and ReviveR AED sup TM /sup More... [09/03] Rochester Leads International Effort to Improve Muscular Dystrophy Treatment More...[09/03] Tibotec Pharmaceuticals Seeks European Marketing Authorization for Investigational Once-Daily HIV Treatment TMC278 More...[09/03] A Chance to Meet Justin Bieber Is Just One Click Away More... [09/02] Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. to Speak at the Keefe Bruyette & Woods Insurance Conference More...[09/02] Starting the School Year Right More...[09/02] Chubb Board Declares Regular Quarterly Dividend More... [08/26] Patent dispute spins around Cedar Fair's new ride More...[08/13] Oracle sues Google for patent infringement More...[08/10] Yahoo heartened by patent verdict More... [08/26] Mass. reaches $1.35M settlement with biotech co. More...[08/19] Billionaire Donald Bren breaks privacy in lawsuit More...[08/12] Judge orders Wells Fargo to pay back $203M in fees More... [06/01] BMW ( 10V254000 ) More...[06/01] VOLKSWAGEN ( 10V252000 ) More...[06/01] FLEETWOOD ( 10V251000 ) More... [09/03] Police: Pa. woman zaps self, brother with stun gun More...[09/02] For 2nd time, Ohio woman gives birth in vehicle More...[09/01] NYC man plunges 40 stories, lands on car, survives More... [09/03] Former egg farm workers say complaints ignored More...[09/01] Federal agents descend on egg farms for 2nd time More...[08/27] Europe probes swine flu shot, narcolepsy link More... [09/03] BP says cost of Gulf of Mexico spill hits $8B More...[09/03] Police question scientist in Miami airport scare More...[09/03] Judge: Paris Hilton may owe $160K over movie deal More... [09/03] Former egg farm workers say complaints ignored More...[09/03] Police: Pa. woman zaps self, brother with stun gun More...[09/02] For 2nd time, Ohio woman gives birth in vehicle More... [09/02] Pike Electric Schedules Fiscal Fourth Quarter and Year End 2010 Financial Results Conference Call More...[09/02] GulfMark to Present at the Barclays Capital CEO Energy-Power Conference More...[09/02] TPC Group Announces Fiscal 2010 Fourth Quarter and Year-End Earnings and Conference Call Schedule More...